Online learning cannot be solely depended on to support educational success for young students. There are three reasons why I take this stance.
1. Students need face-to-face contact with other students and teachers. An important part of classroom instruction is learning social skills and how to work effectively with others. Many students do not know how to relate to their peers or hold a conversation that is not via text message or Facebook. Social skills are an important part of human life. They must be learned and developed in a school setting.
2. Online learning may not be the best mode to teach certain subjects. While straightforward topics such as Math or Keyboarding may be well-suited for computer-based learning, other subjects such as English are not. English courses need an element of discussion and spontaneity that cannot be duplicated by computer instruction. Many English classes use instructional strategies such as role-play that could not be used via online instruction. Students need these different types of strategies to stimulate their learning.
3. Students cannot be trusted to do their own work online from home. Many students would find a way to have another person do their work for them, copy the work of others or simply not do their work. Many students do these things in a school setting with school staff and teachers keeping a watchful eye on them. I do not believe we can trust that students will all be honest and do their own work individually.
While online learning can be used to enhance students understanding of subject matter, we cannot depend on it to fully support education. Students need classroom instruction to develop social skills, learn via the best strategies and be held accountable for their work.
http://www.nytimes.com/roomfordebate/2011/04/05/can-young-students-learn-from-online-classes?partner=rss&emc=rss
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I agree with you Andrea and think you make a good point about honesty and trust with young students. It is more difficult to monitor students' actions while they are working online. I know when I took a correspondence course in college - the precursor to online classes - my brother always assisted me with my homework. I had to take my own tests, and go to an office to do so, I wonder if that is something that could be considered for cyber-school - a proctored exam/assessment.
ReplyDelete